Cougars sophomore third baseman Kade Coombe dove, but missed the tag on Peninsula sophomore outfielder Peter King. Jacob Moore | Kitsap News Group

Cougars sophomore third baseman Kade Coombe dove, but missed the tag on Peninsula sophomore outfielder Peter King. Jacob Moore | Kitsap News Group

Central Kitsap comes up short in comeback bid against Peninsula

The Cougars lost 5-4 after nearly tying the game in the seventh

EAST BREMERTON — Central Kitsap needed four runs in the final frame to force extra innings against Peninsula, but the Cougars were only able to push across three. The Seahawks took the first of a two-game series by a score of 5-4.

For much of the game, all eyes were on the mound. It was a pitcher’s duel at the Kitsap County Fairgrounds with junior Greyson McCormick getting the nod for Central Kitsap and junior Joseph Pierce starting for the Seahawks.

McCormick quickly retired the side in the top half of the first and second innings without giving up a hit, though Peninsula head coach Kevin Owens felt there should have been at least one.

Senior outfielder Cooper Sims hit a slow-roller in the direction of Cougars senior shortstop Fred Buckson, who bare-handed the ball and fired a quick throw to first base. It was a close play, but Sims was called out and Owens expressed his disagreement.

Cougars head coach Bill Baxter said he couldn’t have asked for his starter to pitch a better game.

“He had good command, he got ahead early — he did a really good job,” he said. “Kept us in the game the whole game.”

Meanwhile, Central Kitsap took the early lead against Pierce. He gave up a single to Buckson to lead off the bottom of the first. The next three batters struck out, but Buckson used his legs to plate the first run of the game. He stole second base, reached third on a passed ball and came home on a throwing error.

“[Buckson] is a spark plug for us,” Baxter said. “First pitch of the game, bam, base hit sets the tone … he’s done a nice job for us at the leadoff spot.”

But one run wasn’t enough as the Seahawks clawed their way back into game with a couple of their own. McCormick’s only walk came in the third inning — and it later scored. Peninsula sophomore infielder Reid Sturn singled to bring home the tying run.

Seahawks infielder Andres Vogel stood tall in the batter’s box the following inning, and he nearly broke the 1-1 tie with a homerun to left field. Instead, the ball bounced off the fence and Vogel rolled into second base with a double. With the help of his defense, McCormick worked out of trouble to keep the game even.

“I swear I felt a breeze in my face when I turned around — it kept it in the yard,” Owens said.

Trouble came knocking in the fifth inning. Peninsula sophomore outfielder Peter King led off with a single and took second on a balk. A single and a fielder’s choice followed, allowing King to score and give his team the advantage.

There were some opportunities for Central Kitsap, but a miscue here and some bad luck there made it increasingly difficult as the game progressed. Senior infielder Teagan Taafe was caught stealing in what was supposed to be a hit-and-run in the third inning.

Taafe reached base again in the sixth and moved to second on a sacrifice bunt. Buckson hit a hard line drive that looked as if it was going to score Taafe, who immediately took off for third. Before he could get there, Seahawks senior shortstop Tyler Rogerson gloved the line drive and completed a double play.

Pierce, who wound up with eight strikeouts, showed no signs of a tired arm until the final inning. And even then, he almost completed the game.

“I thought he was excellent all the way through,” Owens said. “He said he was feeling good and he was pitching very well — and we needed every bit of it today.”

In the seventh, Peninsula reached on an error and a single, forcing Central Kitsap head coach Bill Baxter to go to the bullpen. Malo Castro entered the game, but a double, passed ball, error and two walks put the Seahawks up 5-1.

Heading into the bottom of the inning, Central Kitsap needed base runners and got them. With one out, junior catcher Austin McMinds singled, Tristan Barr walked and Reece Wood reached on an error.

A ground out scored one and a single by Carson Wiler brought two more home. He reached second on an error, but the potential tying run was stranded there as Taafe flew out to end the game.

“We can say the what-if game all day long, but it is what it is,” Baxter said. “The great thing about baseball is you get to come back tomorrow and get back at it.”

— Jacob Moore is a reporter for Kitsap Daily News. Contact him at Jmoore@soundpublishing.com.

The Cougars’ Fred Buckson races home in the first inning of the game against Peninsula on March 20. He scored the first run of the game. Jacob Moore | Kitsap News Group

The Cougars’ Fred Buckson races home in the first inning of the game against Peninsula on March 20. He scored the first run of the game. Jacob Moore | Kitsap News Group

Central Kitsap pitcher Greyson McCormick throws a fastball in the top of the third inning to Seahawks hitter Joseph Pierce. Jacob Moore | Kitsap News Group

Central Kitsap pitcher Greyson McCormick throws a fastball in the top of the third inning to Seahawks hitter Joseph Pierce. Jacob Moore | Kitsap News Group

More in Sports

Nick Zeller-Singh
Why Seattle is a perfect spot for 2026 World Cup

Seattle is one of 16 locations in North America to host the… Continue reading

David Musselman worked as a security guard and in customer service for the Seattle Seahawks for nearly seven seasons. Courtesy Photos
Poulsbo firefighter’s path to Seahawks security

First in a series on locals involved with professional sports Dave Musselman… Continue reading

Nicholas Zeller-Singh/Kitsap News Group photos
Kitsap County residents have seen a spike in participation numbers of all ages since the Seattle Kraken started.
Kraken spark more interest in hockey in Kitsap County

The Seattle Kraken pro team has been a hit in Kitsap County,… Continue reading

Salix Wartes-Kahl of NK placed second to lead the Vikings at state. Steve Powell/North Kitsap Herald photos
NK gets 6 Top 5 finishes at 2A state

Salix Wartes-Kahl had the best finish for North Kitsap at the state… Continue reading

Senior catcher Colton Bower was a big reason for NK’s success this season. He will be on scholarship to play for Washington State University next year.
NK baseball stunned in 1st round at state

North Kitsap’s baseball team won over 20 games and only lost a… Continue reading

Makayla Stockman winds up to pitch for the Vikings. Steve Powell/File Photos
NK girls make it to state the hard way

Competitions took place last weekend to see who would advance to the… Continue reading

Pitcher Noah Sorensen moved the ball around and struck out a number of Pirates.
NK wins district title, on to state

Kingston wins 1 before being eliminated

NK's Angel Chavez (8), a junior forward, and Jackson Reeves (12) rush back to defend to keep Clover Park from scoring a breakaway goal. Steve Powell/North Kitsap Herald photos
NK wins in soccer, softball

North Kitsap is still alive in the District 2/3 2A boys soccer… Continue reading

Laine Miller of NK tossed the discus over 142 feet to win the discus. Steve Powell/North Kitsap Herald photos
NK boys, girls win home track meet

Whether it’s for first place, or last, or somewhere in between, high… Continue reading

Kingston sophomore Peau Tameilau (33) slides safety into home plate as catcher Colton Bower of North Kitsap awaits the throw. Steve Powell/North Kitsap Herald photos
NK comes back to beat Kingston

For a little while, it looked like Kingston might upset rival North… Continue reading

The free fishing derby put on by the Lions Club is Saturday in Poulsbo. Courtesy Photo
Free fishing derby Saturday in Poulsbo

The Poulsbo Noon Lions Club is hosting a “Hooked on Fish Derby”… Continue reading

Colton Bower of NK dives safely back to first base after hitting a single in the first inning. Zach Duffy of BHS applies the tag. Steve Powell/North Kitsap Herald
NK falls to league-leading Bainbridge

You can bet the North Kitsap Viking outfielders are going to be… Continue reading